Showing posts with label Mexico. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mexico. Show all posts

Friday, 27 February 2015

Lawyers are disappearing in Mexico and Central America

Karla Zabludovsky has a terrific story on Mexican Lawyers Are Disappearing, Leaving Nothing But Fear And Questions Behind for Buzzfeed.
DURANGO, Mexico — When Claudio Hugo Gallardo disappeared in 2013, his sons scoured the local hospital, prison, and morgue frantically. They combed through video footage recovered from Gallardo’s last known location and even inquired with the cartels whether their operatives had picked up the well-known lawyer.
But before Gallardo’s family could find him, they stopped looking.
“It’s for our own peace. We don’t want threats,” said Claudio Gallardo, one of the attorney’s sons. The family has floated several theories, including the involvement of government officials, cartel thugs, and a combination of both, but prefer to be discreet about their findings, citing orders by local authorities to stop prodding.
Gallardo is one of more than 60 lawyers killed or disappeared here during a spate of crimes against litigators that began in 2008, according to members of Durango’s Benito Juárez Bar Association. Some of the bodies that have been recovered carried messages from criminal groups saying the litigator should not have been defending certain clients, said Celina López Carrera, who is in charge of the state’s public prosecutors.
The Durango attorney general’s office opened a specialized unit to investigate crimes against lawyers in 2010. The unit’s head, Orieta Valles, said none of the 14 cases assigned to it have been solved.
Unfortunately, the murder of lawyers is not confined to Durango, Mexico. From a March 2013 Insight Crime article
More than 50 lawyers were murdered in Honduras between 2010 and 2012, according to a government report, with almost total impunity for their killers.
In the first three years of President Porfirio Lobo's rule 53 lawyers were murdered, yet only two people have been convicted in the cases, according to a report submitted to the Honduran Congress by the country's National Human Rights Commission.
The lawyers, 43 of whom were men, worked not only in criminal law, but also in areas such as commercial and family law, reported La Tribuna. Some worked as public prosecutors, while some provided legal advice to unions and campesino social movements.
The majority were killed inside their vehicles, often in front of their family, friends, colleagues or clients. Of the 53 murders, 49 were carried out with a firearm.
Other reports estimate 68 deaths in Honduras over the three year period.

Meanwhile at least ten lawyers were killed in Guatemala in 2013.

Honestly, I don't remember coming across articles indicating that lawyers were being targeted in El Salvador.

While the press and courts are pressured in all three countries of the Northern Triangle, the extent of the violence is just so much greater in Guatemala and Honduras than it is in El Salvador.

It's hard to build a democratic rule of law when those tasked with carrying out such an important function are targeted by members of the state as well as gangs and organized crime.

Saturday, 21 February 2015

Kino Border Initiative's El Comedor

The Los Angeles Times has a nice write-up on El Comedor along the US-Mexico border in Nogales
El Comedor is sponsored by the Kino Border Initiative, a binational humanitarian effort by religious organizations, including Jesuit Refugee Service / USA, Missionary Sisters of the Eucharist and the Diocese of Tucson. El Comedor served 38,667 meals to migrants in 2014.
I spent a few days volunteering at El Comedor in October 2014. You can read some of my posts here.

You can also learn more about their work and see how you can donate your time or money at the Kino Border Initiative.

Saturday, 1 November 2014

Day of the Dead and Mexico's missing student-teachers



The Christian Science Monitor's Whitney Eulich writes As Day of the Dead looms, families of missing Mexican students hold out hope. One month after the disappearance of 43 college students in Mexico, family members and government authorities are still investigating to find out what happened to them. Instead, all the find are more mass graves without any signs of the missing students.
Orange and yellow marigolds and sugary breads are making an appearance across Mexico City this week as families prepare to celebrate the Nov. 2 Day of the Dead.
To commemorate deceased loved ones on this Catholic-inspired holiday, Mexicans build altars, visit graves, and leave offerings, such as a favorite food or drink.
But for weeks already, some of the parents of the 43 college students who disappeared a month ago in Guerrero state after an encounter with police have gathered around an “altar of hope” on their children's campus. It underscores their demand for answers in what has become a grim national scandal. 
Over 1,200 bodies have been found in mass graves in Mexico since 2006.

I hate to think about this but mass graves / clandestine cemeteries have been found in Mexico and El Salvador. There was a story about a mass grave along the US - Mexico border a few months ago as well. Will they ever uncover similar graves in Guatemala or Honduras?

Wednesday, 29 October 2014

The Battle of the Invisibles - Puebla, Mexico and California



On Tuesday, the University of Scranton's Latin American Studies Program welcomed filmmaker Manuel de Alba to campus to screen his award winning film, The Battle of the Invisibles.
The Battle of the Invisibles: Undocumented Workers vs Supermarkets” is a 60-minute documentary film that focuses on the janitorial labor force from Puebla, Mexico and the exploitation of their labor by major U.S. supermarkets. It also tells the story of how thousands of workers from a rural town in Mexico became employed by California's grocery stores and engaged in a five-year struggle against labor abuses by powerful supermarket chains including Ralphs, Vons and Albertsons.
After years of having been taken advantage of while working as janitors in California, over 2,000 people, many from Puebla, Mexico, joined in a class action lawsuit against the supermarket chains that exploited them. They had suffered lost wages for not being paid the minimum wage, not receiving breaks or vacation days, and were forced to work with toxic chemicals without the proper clothing, gloves, or masks. In the end the supermarkets agreed to an out-of-court settlement of $22 million with the janitors.

It was a very good film that addresses several important issues in immigration and labor exploitation, One of the more interesting targets of the film were the Puebla power brokers who made an economic killing facilitating the travel of their neighbors, often family members, to California and their subsequent exploitation by the supermarket chains.

Thursday, 16 October 2014

They said that San Pedro Sula wasn't that bad and laughed

The Grim Reaper awaits 
On Tuesday, we returned to the Kino Border Initiative (KBI) in Nogales, Mexico. While most of the other Scranton faculty and staff on the trip served food to the migrants, I sat down to help the first time arrivals complete a survey. The survey included questions like their name, age, hometown, where they had been deported from (the border area of living in the US), and whether they had suffered some form of abuse.

I'd say the migrant who moved me the most was Nicolas. He wrote that he was 19 and was traveling with his brother who was 32. However, he looked more like he was 12 years old. Later I learned that he was 14 and his older brother was actually his dad which honestly made more sense. I assume that he said that he was 19 so that he would not be separated from his dad. They had both been recently deported from the United States after getting detained while in transit. The young boy did speak to me but I was affected by the fact that he and his dad were most likely returning to their hometown in the state of Guerrero. Guerrero is the Mexican state where 43 college students were disappeared and presumably killed by police working in cahoots with a local drug gang.

Unlike Monday, all the migrants I spoke to had left their homes primarily because of the lack of work. It seemed that unemployment, violence, and family reunification all played a role but that the lack of economic opportunity was the primary cause for why they had left their homes.

While it wasn't too many, I was surprised at the number of migrants who had lived in the United States without papers but had decided to return home voluntarily. They often returned to Mexico to visit a sick or dying relative. They were then caught returning to the US. While it is somewhat hard to believe, they hadn't realized how much more difficult and dangerous the illegal trip to the US is today than when they had last made the trip a few years ago. They were honestly surprised.

Another migrant stood out. We spoke about Illinois, Colorado, and North Dakota - three states where he had worked before returning to Mexico voluntarily. He was apprehended crossing the border. I asked if he was considering recrossing. He said no. He was returning to his home state (which at this moment I don't remember). He did not want to risk getting apprehended again because a second apprehension would be a felony and result in jail time. Neither he nor his family could risk that. He thanked all the volunteers at KBI in Spanish and then in English which he spoke rather well.

Mexicans are allowed in KBI only after they've been deported and only for a few days. However, Central Americans are welcome to come in and eat even if they haven't attempted the trek to the United States. They are still only allowed to come in for a few days. I spoke to two young men from San Pedro Sula. They hoped to cross the border on Saturday. It was to be the first attempt for the two of them.

I asked if they were leaving San Pedro because of the violence. They looked at each other and sort of laughed. They said that San Pedro wasn't that bad. It sure seemed like a bit of black humor to deal with what is a pretty rough city.

Monday, 13 October 2014

The Nogales, Sonora side of the border


Today, we took the "walk of shame." Well, at least what will become the walk of shame when the new corridor is finished on the Nogales border. It is an enclosed corridor that has been designed to make migrants so feel bad that after they are deported, they will not want to return to the US. Migrants call it the walk of shame because of how they feel after having failed to get to the US or for having been deported after having spent years there. From what I understand, however, migrants returned to Mexico are still being repatriated through the old path.


We then walked to the Kino Border Initiative which serves food and provides services to migrants who have been deported recently. It is a joint initiative supported by several organizations on both sides of the border, including the Jesuits. We helped serve food to about 40 people this morning and maybe another 40 this afternoon. I spent most of my time speaking with the migrants which wasn't really that much time because they are in and out in 45 minutes or so.
I spoke with a few guys from El Salvador and Honduras this morning. Central Americans can use the comedor's services on the way north. However, most of the migrants were from Mexico. They can only use the comedor's services after having been deported and for about a week. Therefore, all the migrants from Mexico had been deported from the US within the last week or so. Some were planning to return home (Oaxaca, Michoacan, Mexico City) while others were going to try to cross the border again, perhaps tonight.

While the Salvadoran and Hondurans spoke about the violence in their country, every person I spoke to placed greater emphasis on family reunification. Some had spent years in the US while others perhaps little or no time at all. However, it seemed as if all of them were trying to get back to the US to reunite with a wife or a child. Several of the men and women broke down and cried.

The most powerful story of the day came from Mary. She has three children with US citizenship and three with Honduran. Her daughter visited Honduras over three years ago. While there, her US passport and that of her nine month old son were stolen. She was able to have a new one issued for herself but there were problems with getting a renewal for her son. Eventually, she returned to the US to continue working on the passport issue. In the meantime, the grandmother who was watching the child witnessed some drug trafficking activity. After going to the police and the human rights office to denounce threats against her, her house was burnt down. She then fled with the boy with nothing but the clothes on her back.

That was in April. She passed through Guatemala and then Mexico on the beast before arriving in Nogales a few weeks ago. She told of some harrowing stories along the way. It looks like the grandson that she has been caring for these last few years will be reunited with his mom in Dallas within the next few weeks. Mary, on the other hand, is going to apply for asylum in the US. She was threatened by the narcotraffickers and then attacked after reporting the threats. Her situation is obviously a difficult asylum case but there's not much she can do.

The cemetery on the right here is where many of the migrants sleep at night if they are unable to afford a hotel or get into a shelter. The groundskeepers lock the gates in the evening so that the migrants are safer than if they were to sleep outside of the gates. There's also some protection from the rain if necessary.

A really powerful day that I am not doing justice too right now but that I thought that I would share.

Friday, 27 December 2013

Mass killing in Central America?

The National Civilian Police in Guatemala recorded 4,881 homicides between January and November 2013. Unfortunately, they have no motive for 2,390 killings (49%) so it makes it really difficult to empirically support many hypotheses regarding violent crime in the country. What I also don't trust in the data is that each killing only falls into a single category. For example, I'm not sure how authorities classified the nine police officers killed in Huehuetenango in June. They had to be placed in either the ignored or revenge category when they could also have fallen under confrontation with the PNC, narco-trafficking, and victims of robbery.

I was only thinking about this because of Jay Ulfelder's post on A Notable Year of the Wrong Kind in which Mexico is the only Latin American country that experienced "mass killing" in 2013. By mass killing, he means "any episode in which the deliberate actions of state agents or other organizations kill at least 1,000 noncombatant civilians from a discrete group." The organizations are probably cartels but I'm not sure if the responsibility is lumped together or broken down by different organizations. I'm also not sure who the discrete group in Mexico is other than civilians but I would probably say "migrants" making their way north to the United States.

Guatemala has suffered between 5,000 and 6,500 murders each year for the last few years, but we don't have exact numbers on who did the killings or who were the victims. Given what we read, one would suspect that gangs, organized crime, and drug traffickers have been responsible for well over 1,000 deaths each year but the PNC's incomplete statistics don't back that up.

El Salvador will "only" experience 2,500 or so murders this year. I suspect that the MS-13 and 18th Street gangs are responsible for at least 1,000 of those deaths but I can't be certain. Honduras will finish the year with over 7,000 murders and a rate over 80 once again but we can't be certain there because the government has stopped sharing homicide statistics. Venezuela will suffer approximately 25,000 murders and finish the year with a murder rate just below 80 per 100,000.

Anybody want to take a crack at which organization/group was responsible for killing over 1,000 members of a specific discrete group in the region in 2013?